- news, features, articles and disease information for the fish industry


Call for Transitional Aid to Support Struggling Scottish Fishing Sector

13 May 2013

SCOTLAND, UK - Large sections of the Scottish whitefish and prawn fleets are teetering on the brink of survival and there is urgent need for transitional aid to prevent the catching sector from being tipped over the edge, the Scottish Fishermen’s Federation is warning the Scottish Government.

In a letter to Fisheries Secretary Richard Lochhead, the SFF says the fishing fleet is ensnared in a web of ‘dysfunctional regulations’ and restrictions that are further exacerbated by on overall depressed market for seafood. While the SFF acknowledges that the Scottish Government has put in place some mitigation measures to help the fleet through these current difficulties, it adds: “Regrettably, despite your efforts, none of these offer remedies. While it is essential that such measures continue, there is now a clear need to address the wider matters of survival.”

The letter, written by SFF chief executive Bertie Armstrong, continues: “At its most fundamental, the catching sector problem lies in the absence of a gap between income achieved for fish at landing and the operating costs of getting them there – grossing figures are one thing, the bottom line is quite another. The gap in fish abundance encountered by fishermen at sea and the constraints of the present technical regulations and quotas is hugely frustrating and continuously expressed by the catching sector.

“This fish abundance is verified by the overall scientific picture of a decade of falling fishing mortality and the corresponding increase in biomass, particularly if taken across the ecosystems. Clearly, the conditions exist for “jam tomorrow”, but while this recovery takes its course and with the additional near-term constraints of a move to Maximum Sustainable Yield (MSY) and some form of land-all obligation, there is, under the present and post CFP reform regulatory framework, going to be no relief for our fishermen today.

“These conditions therefore threaten the survival of large sections of the whitefish and prawn fleets and I do not believe that this is an overstatement. If that is allowed to happen, the demise of the fleets will be accompanied by that of the supporting infrastructure and fishing communities. Perhaps worst of all, there will then be no fishing capacity left to accommodate the fruits of all the sacrifice and effort, when the greatly increased catches under MSY start to become available.

“We can therefore identify a clear transition period between the pressure and constraints of the present and the need to prepare for increased opportunity. This represents a classic case for the need for transitional aid. The details of this will have to be imaginatively worked out, but must embrace all the distressed sectors, and contribute to the preparation for the upturn which will surely follow.”


TheFishSite News Desk

Our Sponsors


Sustainable Aquaculture Modular Courses AVAILABLE NOW - University of St Andrews

Seasonal Picks

Know Your Freshwater Fishes - 5m

Aquacullture Webinars from TheFishSite - Sign Up Now