- news, features, articles and disease information for the fish industry


Discards Ban Could Have Serious Consequences on Fishermen

07 October 2013

SCOTLAND, UK - There is little indication of how the impending introduction of a discards ban will work in practice and if badly implemented the consequences could lead to serious socio-economic difficulties for fragile fishing communities, Alan Coghill, president of the Scottish Fishermen’s Federation, told guests attending the SFF’s annual dinner in Edinburgh.

Mr Coghill told the event, which was attended by Fisheries Minister Richard Lochhead and other leading industry figures, that the gap between political decision-making and the practical implementation of fisheries management measures must be bridged.

“Discards are supported by nobody, least of all the industry, but at the moment there is absolutely no meat on the bones on how a discards ban would be implemented and the scientists have already begun to question the validity and practicality of the exemptions and the flexibility measures suggested,” he said.

“Efforts were made at an early stage to seek a practical solution to achieve a much decreased level of discards, but driven by the extreme environmental lobby, who will ultimately have responsibility for the final biological and socio-economic consequences, government ministers, the Commission and EU Parliament have chosen the ultimate route which may well prove unworkable for some fleets, however hard they try to comply. From a Scottish perspective it is likely to result in a much reduced fleet size with resultant social and economic consequences for already beleaguered fishing communities.”

Mr Coghill will also say that it is essential that the Scottish Government works as closely as possible with the fishing industry with regards to the collation of data on fish stock trends so as to ensure that as much information as possible is fed into the assessment process.

Meanwhile, Bertie Armstrong, SFF chief executive, will also underline the importance of Government and industry in engaging in a constructive way.

“For this process to work – and not just for discards implementation but in all areas of fisheries management - there must be continuous refinement of the engagement between government and fishermen. There needs to be ceaseless work by both the government and industry to continuously improve the communication and cooperation system so as to deliver real and practical results.”

TheFishSite News Desk

Our Sponsors


Sustainable Aquaculture Modular Courses AVAILABLE NOW - University of St Andrews

Seasonal Picks

Know Your Freshwater Fishes - 5m

Aquacullture Webinars from TheFishSite - Sign Up Now