UK - Oil derived from GM Camelina plants that have been modified to produce 20 per cent EPA in their seeds, is entirely suitable for feeding Atlantic salmon, according to new research.
Consumption of omega-3 fish oils, specifically long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids (omega-3 LC-PUFA), through the consumption of oily fish like salmon and mackerel, has been linked with improved cardiovascular health and cognitive development.
The primary dietary sources of these fatty acids are marine fish either wild or farmed (aquaculture). Fish, like humans, accumulate the omega-3 fish oils through the consumption of other organisms in the marine food chain or, in farmed fish, through fishmeal and fish oil in feeds. Currently there is a gap between supply and demand for fish oils and new sources are required for the aquaculture industry and for direct human consumption.
In a collaborative research project between the University of Stirling and Rothamsted Research, scientists developed genetically modified (GM) plants that can produce up to 20 per cent of eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA), one of the two omega-3 LC PUFA conferring health benefits.
The extracted oils from the plants grown in the glass house were used as a replacement for marine fish oil in feeds for Atlantic salmon. The results of the study demonstrated that growth performance, feed efficiency, fish health and nutritional quality for the human consumer were unaffected when dietary fish oil was substituted with oil from the GM plants.
The study is published in the journal Scientific Reports.
Rothamsted Research scientists, strategically funded by the BBSRC, have being carrying out research in metabolically engineering plants to produce omega-3 fish oils for more than 15 years. In the current study they used five microalgal and fungal genes to engineer Camelina plants (Camelina sativa) in order to generate a renewable terrestrial sustainable source of omega-3 fish oils. The oil extracted from these glasshouse grown GM plants was then used to test effective incorporation in fish feeds and the suitability of these feeds for Atlantic salmon.
Dr Monica Betancor, who carried out the experiments at the University of Stirling, commented: “With this work we had the opportunity to test the potential of this novel source of EPA to substitute for fish oil in fish feeds. We used three diets, one containing the standard fish oil used routinely in the fish feed industry, one containing oil from Camelina plants that have not been genetically engineered and one that contained oil derived from plants that have been engineered to produce 20 per cent EPA in their seeds. Each diet was tested with three separate groups of Atlantic salmon for seven weeks.”
“At the end of the experiment we examined fish from the different treatments and found that the oil derived from the GM plants can effectively substitute for fish oil in salmon feeds. This is highly significant because fish oil is a finite and limited resource, very expensive and the increasing demands for it by the fish farming industry will not be met in the future. So we really need to develop effective alternatives like this one,” Dr Betancor concluded.
Professor Johnathan Napier, leading the GM Camelina programme of research at Rothamsted Research, said: "It is very exciting for us to see the results of this study. For us the development of metabolically engineered Camelina plants has been a fascinating project. The findings of the present study are very encouraging as we have always worked towards providing a sustainable source for the omega-3 fish oils – our results here confirm another step in that direction.”
Professor Douglas Tocher, leading the salmon feeding study at the University of Stirling, commented: “There is a fundamental lack of omega-3 LC-PUFA to satisfy the recommended dietary requirements for humans, and fish are our main dietary source. The development of these novel plant oils, tailored to human requirements, represent a sustainable way to farm fish with high levels of omega-3 fish oils that maintain their high nutritional value to the human consumer while preserving wild fish stocks.”
Professor Christine Williams, University of Reading, and an expert on the impact of dietary fats in human health not involved in the present study commented: “Long chain omega 3 fats are essential components of the developing brain and play a vital role in maintaining heart health. However they are made in the body in only very small amounts and need to be supplied in the diet. Although fish are the richest dietary source of these fats there have been concerns about their low levels in farmed fish. In recent years fish farming has needed to use a mixture of fish oils and vegetable oils in the feeds of the fish due to the lack of availability and increasing costs of fish oils. This study showed this novel GM source of long chain omega 3 fats was able to replace fish oils. This will allow farmed fish- the major source of fish in the UK diet- to retain the levels of essential long chain omega-3 fats needed for human health.”
The full scientific paper can be found at http://www.nature.com/srep/2015/150129/srep08104/full/srep08104.html
Go to our previous news item on this story by clicking here.
TheFishSite News Desk